In the latest development regarding Chaos Missouri’s Redistricting, The Chaos of Missouri’s Redistricting Litigation | State Court Report
Key Takeaways & Highlights
- Supreme Court interventions, a Missouri high court decision blocking use of the state’s new congressional map in the coming midterm elections remains intact.
- Alicia Bannon Published: September 9, 2026 Last Updated: September 28, 2026 Missouri Missouri UPDATE: On September 21, the U.S.
- On September 25, the U.S.
Key Background and Context
Main Menu
Close Menu
Latest Developments and Impact Analysis
Election 2026
Voting Rights and Elections
Judicial Interpretation
The Chaos of Missouri’s Redistricting Litigation
After two U.S. Supreme Court interventions, a Missouri high court decision blocking use of the state’s new congressional map in the coming midterm elections remains intact.
Alicia Bannon
Published: September 9, 2026
Last Updated: September 28, 2026
Missouri Missouri
UPDATE: On September 21, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed the federal district court’s TRO and ordered entry of a permanent injunction requiring use of the new congressional map that had been blocked by the Missouri Supreme Court. On September 25, the U.S.
Supreme Court stayed this ruling and ordered that the 2022 map be used in the general election. Last week, the Missouri Supreme Court unanimously blocked use of the state’s new gerrymandered congressional map in the 2026 midterm election, applying a state constitutional provision that allows voters to put new laws up for a referendum before they take effect.
The ruling prompted a flurry of federal court activity this week: On Tuesday, Justice Brett Kavanaugh rejected a shadow docket application seeking to halt the state high court’s ruling. Minutes later, a federal district court issued a temporary restraining order in a separate federal case, ordering that the new map be used in the general election.
And then on Thursday, the U.S. Supreme Court stayed the district court’s order. This means that Missouri will use its original congressional map in November, as ordered by the Missouri Supreme Court, and voters will also consider a referendum as to whether to accept or reject the new map going forward.
In a year that has seen a dizzying number of legal fights over mid-decade partisan gerrymanders, this late entry by Missouri may well be the messiest. But after a flood of litigation over the past week — including contempt proceedings before the state supreme court after Secretary of State Denny Hoskins instructed election officials to use the new map — state officials have affirmed that the state will comply with the state high court’s order and use the original map this November.
Looking forward, what this saga underscores is that courts need stronger tools to address gamesmanship in redistricting and election disputes. Indeed, what struck me most about the Missouri Supreme Court’s decision last week in von Glahn v. Hoskins was its sharp words about delay by the secretary of state and its rejection of his argument that it was too late for the court to act.
Courts often hesitate to make changes to election rules as Election Day draws near. (Federal courts apply a doctrine known as the Purcell principle to this effect.) It’s an approach that’s understandable in some circumstances but can also incentivize shenanigans to evade judicial review while harming voters’ rights.
The Missouri high court ruling models a different approach and was a strong statement by the court that it wouldn’t tolerate chicanery that undercuts Missourians’ referendum rights. But this saga should also prompt reflection about how courts can address these kinds of conflicts sooner.
The dispute originated in September 2025, when the Missouri legislature passed House Bill 1. The law sought to replace the state’s existing congressional map with a more extreme 7–1 Republican gerrymander, part of mid-decade gerrymandering efforts across the country. Soon after, voters initiated a referendum campaign to reject the map.
Under the state constitution, Missourians have a right to approve or reject acts of the state legislature via referendum. The state constitution provides that when voters successfully put a referendum on the ballot, the challenged law does not take effect until after voters approve it.
In December 2025, referendum organizers submitted more than 300,000 signatures to the secretary of state challenging H.B. 1. Under state law, Hoskins then had to assess the referendum petition and issue a certificate determining whether it met all legal requirements. If the petition was valid, a referendum on H.B. 1 would appear on the ballot.
Time passed. And passed further. As early as December 2025, Hoskins asserted in separate federal litigation that a referendum on redistricting was not authorized by the state constitution. But he held off on issuing a certificate on that basis — which would have triggered judicial review — instead going through a lengthy process of verifying petition signatures.
And while state law offers an option to verify signatures through random sampling, Hoskins chose to require individual review of every signature submitted. Finally, on August 4 at 4 p.m., an hour before the secretary of state’s statutory deadline to issue a certificate — and the day Missouri was holding its primary election using the map passed in H.B. 1 — Hoskins ruled that the petition was legally insufficient.
Asserting that the state constitution does not allow for referenda on congressional redistricting plans passed by the legislature, Hoskins directed that the petition be kept off the ballot. A proponent of the referendum filed suit the same day. After a lower court upheld Hoskins’s determination, the state supreme court took up an expedited appeal and concluded that the referendum was authorized under the state constitution.
The court pointed to the constitution’s plain text, in which the people “reserve power to approve or reject by referendum any act of the general assembly” and concluded that none of the exceptions laid out in the state constitution were relevant. The result, the court explained, was that under the state constitution, “HB 1 is not the law and has never been the law.
There is only one valid congressional redistricting in effect — the congressional redistricting the General Assembly established in 2022.” Nor did the overlap between the primary date and Hoskins’s statutory deadline change the court’s analysis. The state constitution’s right of referendum came first, and a “later-enacted statute has no bearing on the constitution’s plain language.” As a result, the court concluded, the general election must be held using the district lines laid out in the 2022 map.
With respect to timing, the court took pains to point out that it was the secretary of state’s delay that “created the confusion, expense, and practical difficulties of which he complains.” Because “the secretary delayed certification until the last possible date and chose not to seek resolution of the constitutional question,” the court found his objections about the timing of the court’s ruling “wholly unpersuasive.” Following the court’s ruling, congressional candidates and voters filed a new federal lawsuit, arguing that holding a general election using different maps than those used in the primary would violate their federal constitutional rights.
This formed the basis for Tuesday’s temporary restraining order, with the district court concluding that the plaintiffs’ equal protection rights, as well as their right to have their primary ballot counted under Article I, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution, were likely violated.
Not surprisingly, the Supreme Court stayed this ruling. Significantly, the Court has both repeatedly tolerated last-minute changes to election maps by states, including voiding ballots that had already been cast, and rejected late-stage interventions by federal courts. But putting aside the legal questions, it’s also undeniable that Missouri voters are facing a chaotic and potentially confusing landscape in the run-up to Election Day.
Back in May, the state supreme court rejected a lawsuit seeking to block H.B. 1 while the secretary of state’s certification process was still ongoing. Had the court found a way to rule on this conflict at that stage, it could have moved the primary, for example, or set a hard deadline for certifying the referendum petition.
In a world of election hardball, courts should look hard at how they can use their powers flexibly to protect voters. Alicia Bannon is editor in chief for State Court Report. She is also director of the Judiciary Program at the Brennan Center for Justice. Suggested Citation: Alicia Bannon, The Continuing Chaos of Missouri’s Redistricting Litigation, Sᴛᴀᴛᴇ Cᴏᴜʀᴛ Rᴇᴘᴏʀᴛ (Sept. 9, 2026, updated Sept. 28, 2026), https://statecourtreport.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/continuing-chaos-missouris-redistricting-litigation
Related Commentary
Election 2026
Voting Rights and Elections
Fed up Missourians Vote to Strengthen Direct Democracy Rights
After years of state lawmakers and officials trying to limit those rights and repeal voter-approved initiatives, Missourians last week passed strong protections against future attacks.
Alice Clapman
Missouri Missouri
Arizona Arizona
Utah Utah
Montana Montana
North Dakota North Dakota
South Dakota South Dakota
Florida Florida
Arkansas Arkansas
November 10, 2026
Election 2026
Voting Rights and Elections
Reproductive Rights
Civil Rights
Government Structure
Criminal Law
Education
What 2026 Ballot Measure Results Tell Us
Results on measures relating to abortion, redistricting, voter ID requirements, and other issues were mixed; citizens were unified in protecting their ballot measure rights.
Erin Geiger Smith
Missouri Missouri
Arkansas Arkansas
Kansas Kansas
South Dakota South Dakota
West Virginia West Virginia
Alaska Alaska
Arizona Arizona
Michigan Michigan
Montana Montana
California California
Oklahoma Oklahoma
Colorado Colorado
Nevada Nevada
North Carolina North Carolina
Ohio Ohio
Massachusetts Massachusetts
Virginia Virginia
North Dakota North Dakota
Utah Utah
Maryland Maryland
Idaho Idaho
Nebraska Nebraska
Washington Washington
Louisiana Louisiana
New Mexico New Mexico
Wisconsin Wisconsin
Kentucky Kentucky
Vermont Vermont
Alabama Alabama
November 9, 2026
Election 2026
Reproductive Rights
Voting Rights and Elections
Voters in Missouri, Nevada, and Virginia Opt to Protect Reproductive Rights
In Idaho, a ballot measure that would have guaranteed reproductive freedom and privacy failed.
Mary Ziegler
Missouri Missouri
Nevada Nevada
Virginia Virginia
Idaho Idaho
November 5, 2026
Election 2026
Judicial Selection and Administration
Criminal Law
Civil Rights
Voting Rights and Elections
State Supreme Court Election Results Tee Up Fights for Court Majorities in 2028
Democrats and liberal candidates won in Montana, North Carolina, Ohio, and Texas, among other key races.
Alicia Bannon,
Douglas Keith
Montana Montana
Ohio Ohio
Texas Texas
North Carolina North Carolina
November 5, 2026
A project of the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU Law
© 2026 Brennan Center for Justice at NYU Law
Privacy Policy
Accessibility

Comments 0
Leave a Comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!