In the latest development regarding Jensen Thornell American, Jensen v. Thornell | American Civil Liberties Union
Key Takeaways & Highlights
- Thornell | American Civil Liberties Union Key Background and Context Skip navigation Jensen v.
- Thornell is a federal lawsuit challenging medical care, mental health care, and conditions in maximum custody isolation units in Arizona state prisons.
- The case, which previously has been called Jensen v.
Key Background and Context
Skip navigation
Jensen v. Thornell Prisoners' Rights Location: Arizona Status: Closed (Judgment) Last Update: July 17, 2026
Latest Developments and Impact Analysis
What's at Stake UPDATE: On July 17, 2026, U.S. District Judge Roslyn O. Silver issued an order formally appointing a receiver to assume control and management of health care provided to more than 25,000 people incarcerated in Arizona Department of Corrections, Rehabilitation, and Reentry (ADCRR) prisons, in a long-running lawsuit against the state prison system brought by the Prison Law Office, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), ACLU of Arizona, and Disability Rights Arizona.
More details here.
Summary
Jensen v. Thornell is a federal lawsuit challenging medical care, mental health care, and conditions in maximum custody isolation units in Arizona state prisons. The case, which previously has been called Jensen v. Shinn and Parsons v. Ryan, is a class action on behalf of all people housed in the nine (formerly ten) Arizona state prisons.
The lawsuit sought only to change the policies and practices of the Arizona Department of Corrections, Rehabilitation & Reentry (ADCRR), and did not seek money damages. The case was filed in March 2012 by the Prison Law Office, the ACLU, Disability Rights Arizona, and other lawyers.
Although the parties settled this case in October 2014, the state consistently failed to follow the terms of that settlement. So, in July 2021, Judge Silver rescinded the court’s approval of the settlement, and the parties went to trial in the fall of 2021. After a fifteen-day trial held in November and December 2021, Judge Silver issued a 200-page order on June 30, 2022, finding that ADCRR violates the constitutional rights of people in prison.
The evidence at trial showed that incarcerated people suffered excruciating pain, permanent injuries, and preventable deaths due to the state’s failures to provide health care. The court found that the “health care system is plainly grossly inadequate. Defendants have been aware of their failures for years and Defendants have refused to take necessary actions to remedy the failures.” The court also found that the treatment of people in the detention units was shocking, and that ADCRR kept “hundreds of prisoners in maximum custody housing despite all prison officials admitting there is no penological justification for doing so.” On April 7, 2023, Judge Silver issued a 57-page order (called an Injunction) requiring ADCRR to fix the constitutional violations.
She appointed four experts to serve as neutral monitors to assist the court in monitoring ADCRR’s compliance with the Injunction. The Injunction required ADCRR to make “substantial” changes to staffing and conditions so that medical care and mental healthcare at Arizona prisons come up to constitutional standards.
On February 11, 2025, we filed a motion asking the federal court to appoint a receiver to oversee health care in Arizona state prisons. A receivership is a legal process in which a neutral third party (the receiver) is appointed by a court to take day-to-day management over the subject of litigation.
Starting in the civil rights era, federal courts have appointed receivers to manage public institutions, for example, when local governments refused to desegregate public schools. Receivers have been appointed by federal courts to run prisons, jails, and child welfare agencies. Receiverships are rare, and occur in cases when less intrusive remedial efforts of the courts have failed.
On February 19, 2026, Judge Silver issued a 128-page order granting our motion for a receiver, stating: To declare a government will not accept the constitutional responsibility to provide adequate healthcare is huge. Ordering the implementation of a receivership is extraordinary, and the Court has exercised caution and critical reflection in making the decision.
But since the beginning of the case, the Court has forborne imposing the harshest penalties, opting instead to guide Defendants with the help of the Monitors towards comprehensive constitutional compliance. But now after nearly 14 years of litigation with Defendants having not gained compliance, or even a semblance of compliance with the Injunction and the Constitution, this approach has not only failed completely, but, if continued, would be nothing short of judicial indulgence of deeply entrenched unconstitutional conduct.
Plainly, only the imposition of the extraordinary can bring an end to this litigation and the reasons it was brought. An end to unconstitutional preventable suicides. An end to unconstitutional preventable deaths. An end to unconstitutional failures to treat those in severe pain.
The Motion for a Receiver will be granted.
Legal Documents
07/17/2026 Jensen v. Thornell: Order Appointing Chambers-Smith as Receiver
Jensen v. Thornell: Order Appointing Chambers-Smith as Receiver Doc. 5307, Order Appointing Chambers-Smith as Receiver Date Filed: 07/17/2026 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document
02/19/2026 Jensen v. Thornell: Order Appointing Receiver
Jensen v. Thornell: Order Appointing Receiver Doc. 5123, Order granting Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Receiver Date Filed: 02/19/2026 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
02/11/2025 Jensen v. Thornell: Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Receiver
Jensen v. Thornell: Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Receiver Doc. 4792 Date Filed: 02/11/2025 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
01/07/2025 Jensen v. Thornell: Court Monitors’ Second Interim Report
Jensen v. Thornell: Court Monitors’ Second Interim Report Doc. 4755 Date Filed: 01/07/2025 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
10/17/2024 Jensen v. Thornell: Court Monitors’ Report on Five Suicides
Jensen v. Thornell: Court Monitors’ Report on Five Suicides Doc. 4691 Date Filed: 10/17/2024 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
04/07/2023 Jensen v. Thornell: Order and Permanent Injunction
Jensen v. Thornell: Order and Permanent Injunction Doc. 4410 Date Filed: 04/07/2023 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
06/30/2022 Jensen v. Shinn: Findings of Fact Post-Trial
Jensen v. Shinn: Findings of Fact Post-Trial Doc. 4335 Date Filed: 06/30/2022 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
02/24/2021 Parsons v. Ryan: Contempt Order
Parsons v. Ryan: Contempt Order Judge Holds Arizona Department of Corrections in Contempt for the Second Time in Three Years (Doc. 3861) Date Filed: 02/24/2021 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
06/22/2018 Parsons v. Ryan: Order and Judgement of Civil Contempt
Parsons v. Ryan: Order and Judgement of Civil Contempt Doc. 2898 Date Filed: 06/22/2018 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
10/10/2017 Parsons v. Ryan: Order re Civil Contempt Sanctions
Parsons v. Ryan: Order re Civil Contempt Sanctions Date Filed: 10/10/2017 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
04/11/2016 Parsons v. Ryan: Motion to Enforce
Parsons v. Ryan: Motion to Enforce Date Filed: 04/11/2016 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
04/05/2016 Parsons v. Ryan: Dr. Todd Wilcox Expert Report
Parsons v. Ryan: Dr. Todd Wilcox Expert Report Date Filed: 04/05/2016 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
10/14/2014 Parsons v. Ryan: Index of Exhibits to Stipulation
Parsons v. Ryan: Index of Exhibits to Stipulation Date Filed: 10/14/2014 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
10/09/2014 Parsons v. Ryan: Stipulation
Parsons v. Ryan: Stipulation Date Filed: 10/09/2014 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
08/29/2014 Parsons v. Ryan: Dr. Pablo Stewart Expert Report
Parsons v. Ryan: Dr. Pablo Stewart Expert Report Date Filed: 08/29/2014 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
08/07/2014 Parsons v. Ryan: Order Denying Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment
Parsons v. Ryan: Order Denying Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment Doc. 1065 Date Filed: 08/07/2014 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Older document Newer document
06/05/2014 Parsons v. Ryan: 9th Circuit Opinion
Parsons v. Ryan: 9th Circuit Opinion Doc. 61-1 Date Filed: 06/05/2014 Affiliate: Arizona Download document
Skip to PDF content
Newer document
Press Releases
Oct 01, 2026
Supreme Court Rejects Arizona’s Attempt to Halt Court-Ordered Oversight of Prison Health Care
Supreme Court Rejects Arizona’s Attempt to Halt Court-Ordered Oversight of Prison Health Care
Jul 20, 2026
Federal Judge Appoints Former Ohio Corrections Leader as Receiver to Manage Health Care in Arizona Prisons
Federal Judge Appoints Former Ohio Corrections Leader as Receiver to Manage Health Care in Arizona Prisons
Feb 11, 2025
Advocates Move to Appoint Receiver to Oversee Healthcare in Arizona Prisons
Advocates Move to Appoint Receiver to Oversee Healthcare in Arizona Prisons
Jan 09, 2023
Federal Judge Issues Sweeping Remedial Order to Arizona Prison Officials
Federal Judge Issues Sweeping Remedial Order to Arizona Prison Officials
Jul 01, 2022
Federal Court Finds Conditions in Arizona State Prisons Unconstitutional
Federal Court Finds Conditions in Arizona State Prisons Unconstitutional
Feb 25, 2021
Judge Holds Arizona Department of Corrections in Contempt for the Second Time in Three Years
Judge Holds Arizona Department of Corrections in Contempt for the Second Time in Three Years
News & Commentary
One Year Later, Hope for Humanity in Arizona Prisons A year after being ordered to address negligent and abusive conditions, there are glimmers of change in Arizona prisons. But the work continues.
One Year Later, Hope for Humanity in Arizona Prisons
Arizona Violated the Rights of Incarcerated People for More Than a Decade. That Will Finally End. A judge is holding Arizona accountable after hearing from our incarcerated clients about the abuse they endured in custody.
Arizona Violated the Rights of Incarcerated People for More Than a Decade. That Will Finally End.
We Are Holding Arizona Accountable for the Needless Suffering and Deaths of Incarcerated People For years the state has permitted medical neglect and cruel treatment of people in solitary confinement, despite a settlement.
We Are Holding Arizona Accountable for the Needless Suffering and Deaths of Incarcerated People
We Know Prisons Need COVID-19 Plans, but our Arizona Prison Tour Suggests it’s not Happening Arizona prisons have notoriously bad health care under normal circumstances. These are not normal circumstances.
We Know Prisons Need COVID-19 Plans, but our Arizona Prison Tour Suggests it’s not Happening
Federal Judge Finds Arizona’s Prison Health Care Is "Plainly Grossly Inadequate" and Unconstitutional After a long struggle, a damning ruling affirms what our plaintiffs have endured for years.
Federal Judge Finds Arizona’s Prison Health Care Is "Plainly Grossly Inadequate" and Unconstitutional
Support our on-going litigation and work in the courts
Donate now
Related Issues
Prisoners' Rights
Medical and Mental Health Care
Solitary Confinement
Cruel, Inhuman, and Degrading Conditions

Comments 0
Leave a Comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!